Skip to main content
PetInsuranceDenied

Methodology

How we research and why you can trust it

Source rules

  1. 1.Primary source only.Every fact about a carrier's appeal procedure is sourced to that carrier's own page (their /claims, /appeal, /faq URLs, or their published policy doc PDF). Every fact about a state insurance commissioner is sourced to that state's own DOI website.
  2. 2.No third-party scrapers. Bankrate, NerdWallet, Money.com, Pawlicy, Forbes, U.S. News — these are downstream summaries. We do not cite them as primary sources for any factual claim about a carrier or a state DOI.
  3. 3.Verbatim quotes.Where we quote carrier policy language (e.g., the pre-existing condition definition), the quote is verbatim — and the source URL is published in the citation list. Where the quote is provisional (extracted from a search-engine snippet, awaiting browser-render verification), the page is flagged with a “verification pending” pin.
  4. 4.Honest gap-flagging.Where a carrier doesn't publish a fact (e.g., Lemonade doesn't state an appeal-window day-count, Healthy Paws doesn't publish a multi-level appeal structure), we mark the field “verification pending” rather than fabricating a number. Operator follow-up is tracked in the page's citation list.
  5. 5.No fabricated win-rates.We do not publish “X% of appeals on this ground succeed” statistics. Carrier-level appeal-success data is not published at sufficient granularity to support such a claim. Our denial-reason pillars list documented procedural moves; outcomes are case-specific.

Update cadence

Carrier appeal procedures change. Mailing addresses move. State commissioners are appointed and replaced. Every page carries a “Last verified” date.

We re-verify each carrier's appeal procedure on a quarterly cadence (or sooner if a reader reports a stale fact). State DOI commissioner data is reviewed annually around state-insurance- department leadership cycles.

Privacy contract for the Appeal Letter Generator

The Appeal Letter Generator is the AIO-defense wedge of this site — and it's also the place where a careless implementation could collect protected vet-record data. So we wrote a hard contract:

  • •The generator runs entirely in your browser. The PDF is built client-side via the jsPDF library; the bundle ships only when you reach the download step.
  • •The pet name, diagnosis, policy section, vet-record filenames, claim number, and your name and address are stored in browser memory only. Closing the tab clears them.
  • •We do NOT persist them to localStorage. We do NOT POST them. We do NOT serialize them over the network in any form.
  • •The two analytics events fired by the generator are generator_step (step number only) and generator_outcome (carrier slug + denial-reason slug only — no free text). Both are visible in the source under src/components/layout/analytics.tsx.
  • •The PDF download uses an in-browser blob: URL — your appeal letter never traverses our servers in any form.

If the contract above ever weakens — for any reason — theprivacy promiseelsewhere on this site becomes a lie. Anyone modifying the generator should leave a note here documenting the change.

Affiliate disclosure

We earn referral fees when readers sign up for certain third-party programs through our links — primarily alternative pet insurance carriers (Trupanion, Lemonade, Embrace) and consumer financing platforms. The fee is paid by the third-party. It does not change the price you pay. It does not influence the appeal advice on this site — we earn nothing from your appeal succeeding, and the appeal path is what we recommend first.

We use Google Analytics to understand which carrier hubs and denial-reason pillars are most useful. We never log the specific inputs you put into the Appeal Letter Generator — that runs entirely in your browser. Read our privacy policy.